A few things about the area your Hutchinsons came from which might help.
Windermere was called Applethwaite until the 19th C., so to find strays - people who were born there but living somewhere else - in the census you need to look up both. There were a group of Hutchinsons - Nathan, James and Robert living there in the late 18th C, and they all had a number of children, though I couldn't tell you who they all were. James lived at Common, a farmhouse which still exists just off the road between Windermere and
Staveley. There was also a William, who lived at Winster and
Crook, which roughly speaking are between Bowness/Windermere and
Staveley.
The Hutchinsons disappear from Windermere in the early 19th C, but in 1851 most of their descendants live very close by, and in 1851 two of them, Nathan and Isaac, are farming at
Staveley.
Windermere
Parish Church is in
Bowness beside the lake, and the parish includes
Bowness (formerly Undermillbeck) and Windermere (formerly Applethwaite). All the other places are in the vast parish of Kendal, which had a large number of chapels of ease including
Staveley and
Crook. The IGI usually puts all entries under Kendal, so you can't tell whether people lived in the town of Kendal or one of the outlying districts, but the chapels actually kept their own registers. The chapel registers are often quite small so it's easy to find someone, though some were so small they did not always have a priest, so families might use a neighbouring one. The records of Windermere and Kendal parishes are on microfilm at Kendal Record Office.
I have a lot of records for Windermere but not
Staveley. If I find anything that might be useful to you I'll let you know.
