Cindy,
I thought with a name like Voegtly, you must have roots here in Pgh. I just checked the partial listing that is on the internet for Voegtly Cemetery (located on Troy Hill) to see if there was a listing for your Michael(
http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.com/~njm1/voegtly.htm). Sorry, there was no Michael. My ggg-grandfather, gg-grandfather and gg-grandmother, various uncles and aunts are buried in this cemetery. I knew that Nicholas was from Swizterland so I hoped that your Michael just might have been, too. I wonder why he was attracted to a church that was frequented by a large
Swiss population. Do you think that they were related at all? My g-grandmother is buried in Smithfield Church's cemetery, so you and I have similarities in our background. I did have a very hard time finding her, it took years. She lived in the Old
Folks home near
Baden, PA and I looked through a lot of cemeteries in that area (
Beaver Co). After I accidently found her listed on the 1920 census while I was at the Seattle Nat'l Archives, my brother requested a "ten year search" through the PA vital records dept. and they found a death certificate listing her burial site as Smithfield Cemetery. It turns out that the Old
Folks Home where my ggmother died was located in a popular vacation spot for the wealthier residents of
Allegheny City. It's not far from
Allegheny City by today's standards, but back then, it probably was a full days journey. I never would have guessed that she would be buried in Smithfield instead of Voegthly as all her family. I had searched the records of Voegtly Church that were at
Hillman Library. I also knew that my particular family also belong to St. Paul's Evang. Lutheran Church on
Avery St. which was near Voegtly Church. There was, I believe, a St. Peter's located there also. All those records can be viewed at Hillman's, also. But, since you are not local, I know that St. Paul's can be ordered through the LDS library. Our LDS keeps their copy at their branch in
Greentree instead of returning them to Salt Lake. The actual records are supposed to be in St. Louis (
Eden Seminary). I believe that denomination is now part of the Church of
Christ or Church of the Brethern - it's not Lutheran. My ancesters were Jenny's(
Swiss), Schlegel's(
German),
McGinnis(Scottish/Irish),
Rebholz(Alsatian) and others. I don't get out to the main library much, but when I do, I shall be on the lookout for Michael Voegtly. Do you have any more info about him. Did he remain here in Pgh? In
Allegheny City? Were you able to check city directories? Censuses? Do you know when he died? I don't know what access you have to Pgh research or whether you come back regularly to do your searching. I wish you luck in finding Michael.