Thank you for the additional information, Bruce. I would be interested in the children's birth dates.
The
Potts Family Genealogy website lists Susanna as the daughter of John
Hallowell and Alice
Potts, too, but I do not believe the website provides source information, so I am not sure if it is reliable. Perhaps
Hinshaw is the source, but I have not seen the
Hinshaw source you reference. I will look for it.
"The Hallowell-Paul Family," available on Ancestry.com, says that John
Hallowell and Alice
Potts had five children, four boys and one girl, but no Susanna. However, one of these boys is Samuel E., b. 1806. Could this be a twin of Susanna, or could it have been transcribed incorrectly from a handwritten source? This book does not provide any further information on this Samuel E.