Your FISHEL responses were excellent and added some names to my file also, for which - thanks. Apparently there may have been two men named "Adam Fishel" - one ending life in IL, the other in IN. Otherwise, Adam Fishel (1818-1897) of Bart Co, IN, would need to have married again (McCoy) and been age 61 as "father" of Susan. Possible, of course.
My GILLILAND individuals in Bart County, IN, include GILLILAND spouses named: WASON, BARRETT, ROTHROCK, POINTER, DRAKE. Daughter of Elizabeth Lydia Rominger & Adam Fishel (1818-1897), Sina FISHEL m. John GILLILAND (your/your husband's line?). Walter Q BRADLEY m. Clara GILLILAND.
Lots of ROMINGER research has been done, back to Germany in the 15th century. One Rominger book is over 520 pages. Another book over 100 pages, took over 60 years' research, up to 1939.
For very helpful, Moravian Church history & connections:
Web site: http://users.erols.com/fmoran/
Good luck, Ruth