I know your original post was years ago, but I am hoping that you are still able to reply. What was the source you used to look up slave holders during this period? I ask, because it might be of benefit to me, and help explain the lack of other governmental documentation for part of my family in Rockbridge County in the middle to late 1800's.
They reportedly were just outside of Brownsburg, possibly near Walker's Creek at the time of birth of my Great Grandfather, Andrew Willson Scott (spelled with two "L's" in his 1936 Social Security Number Application), b. 1875, Rockbridge County.
I cannot find ANYTHING about him in Rockbridge County (or Virginia for that matter), nor clear confirmation of his parents, George Washington Scott and Mary Susan Frances Moyers (aside from Andrew Scott stating so in his 1936 Social Security application). There is some confusion about which parent—but reportedly, one of them was of "Indian" heritage (as stated in the census of 1930 for their son Andrew Scott). There may also be some African heritage mixed in at some point. This further complicates research, as they may have "hidden" or misrepresented in enumeration as "black". My understanding is that slave documentation is difficult to match, especially with only a first name given on a list, if that; and not all Native American Rolls were complete and some inaccurate. Complicated.
So, for years this has been a large mystery and frustrating stone wall for me.
Andrew was categorized in the 1912 marriage index (in NC) as "black"; 1920 census (NC) as "black"; in 1930 census (OH) as "Indian" and in his 1936 Social Security Application (OH) also as "Indian". Perhaps it was not until 1930 that he felt (or was given the social/governmental opportunity) that he could be more comfortable in embracing the ethnicity "Indian"—no longer living in VA or NC. I have no pictures to even speculate with on Andrew.
I have an old, short telephone interview with one of Andrew's daughters (his youngest child and now deceased), and she spoke of Indian heritage indirectly. "We never even mentioned the word 'Indian' for fear of what someone might do to us". She went on to say that, "Indians were treated worse than blacks in those days."
Andrew's son (my maternal Grandfather), Walter M. Scott (deceased 3 months before my birth) was married 3 times, and his third wife (before she passed away) told me the Scott's were Cherokee.
I appreciate any help you might offer or point me to.